Most contractors do honest work, and a little preparation makes it easier to tell them apart from the few who don’t. That preparation matters more in Maine than in many states: the Maine Attorney General points out that general contractors, and trades such as roofing and framing, are not licensed or regulated here, and that its Consumer Mediation Program gets more complaints about contractors than any other kind of business. For how to look up the trades Maine does license, see our guide on checking a contractor in Maine.
Before you hire
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Maine Attorney General suggest:
- Get several written estimates. Each should describe the work, the materials, the completion date and the price. Don’t automatically choose the lowest bid, and ask why if the estimates are far apart.
- Ask for referrals from people you trust, and check references.
- Look for complaints. The Attorney General’s Consumer Protection Division can tell you whether a contractor has been the subject of a consumer complaint (1-800-436-2131, or online). The Attorney General also publishes a list of home contractors the State has sued.
- Ask for proof of insurance.
Jobs over $3,000 need a written contract
Maine’s Home Construction Contracts Act covers building, remodeling or repairing a home with three or fewer living units, including electrical, plumbing and heating work, carpeting, window replacements and other non-structural work. For any job over $3,000 in materials or labor, the contract must be in writing, signed by both you and the contractor, and you each get a copy before work starts. The law says it must include:
- Names, addresses and phone numbers of you and the contractor, and the location of the work.
- Estimated start and substantial completion dates.
- The total price, or for “cost-plus” work, the agreed price and an estimate of labor and materials.
- The method of payment, with the down payment limited to no more than one-third of the total price.
- A general description of the work and materials.
- A warranty statement that the work will be free from faulty materials, built to the building code that applies where you live, done in a skillful manner and fit for its use.
- A choice of how to settle disputes that small claims court can’t resolve: binding arbitration, non-binding arbitration or mediation.
- A change order statement: any change that alters the price is made only through a written change order.
- The Attorney General’s consumer protection information on home construction and repair, attached as an addendum, and a notice pointing you to the Attorney General’s website and phone number.
The law also lists a few more items for particular jobs, such as cancellation rights for door-to-door sales and disclosures when insulation goes into an existing home.
The Attorney General publishes a model home construction contract and change order that meet these requirements. You’re free to copy and use them.
Changes to the job
Any change that alters the price has to be written up as a change order, signed by both of you, stating the previous price and the revised price.
Waiving these protections
You and the contractor can agree to leave out the required parts of the contract, but only if the contractor first tells you about your rights under the law and you both agree. The Attorney General stresses that you don’t have to give up these rights to hire a contractor, so make sure you understand what you’d be giving up if you’re asked to.
How much to pay up front
Under the law, the down payment is limited to one-third of the total contract price unless you’ve agreed to waive that requirement as described above. The FTC advises against paying the full amount up front, and against making the final payment until the work is finished and you’re satisfied with it.
Mechanic’s liens and lien waivers
The Attorney General warns that a contractor or subcontractor who works on your home or land can file a mechanic’s lien against your home if they aren’t paid, even without a written contract, as long as you agreed to the work. Its advice is to ask for a lien waiver each time you make a payment, as evidence that the payment was received, and to contact an attorney right away if a lien is filed on your property.
Building codes and permits
The Attorney General notes that towns with more than 4,000 residents must enforce the Maine Uniform Building and Energy Code for new construction and additions, and suggests asking for a contract term that the work will be done to that code. Your town’s code enforcement office can tell you which permits a project needs. Our town pages, such as Portland, link to each town’s website.
Warning signs
The FTC lists these as common tactics of home improvement scammers:
- Knocking on your door because they’re “in the area”, or saying they have materials left over from another job.
- Pressuring you to decide right away.
- Asking for full payment up front, or taking only cash.
- Asking you to get the building permits.
- Suggesting you borrow from a lender they know.
On financing, the FTC’s advice is never to take a loan arranged by a contractor without comparing other offers, never to sign anything you haven’t read or that has blank spaces, and never to sign over your deed without advice from an attorney or someone you trust.
If something goes wrong
The Maine Attorney General suggests matching your response to the problem:
- Work left unfinished or done wrong: write to the contractor listing what still needs doing and ask them to say within 10 days when it will be finished. Keep a copy. If they don’t respond or won’t finish, you can hire someone else and seek the cost from the original contractor.
- Poor work throughout: have an independent contractor inspect it and give you a written report of what’s wrong and what it will cost to fix, then write to your contractor asking them to pay that cost.
- No work done at all: write to cancel the contract and ask for your money back, giving a reasonable time to respond, such as 14 to 30 days.
If that doesn’t settle it, the Attorney General notes you can sue in Small Claims Court yourself for claims under $10,000, and should speak with an attorney about larger claims. You can also file a complaint with the Attorney General’s Consumer Protection Division and ask for mediation. Maine law also makes home construction or repair fraud a crime, for example promising work the contractor doesn’t intend to do, and you can report it to the police.